One of the most common questions in home winemaking is: can wine kits actually taste like store-bought wine?
The answer is yes — but not all wine kits (or wine styles) behave the same.
From experience, the biggest difference isn’t just how long the kit takes. It’s the style of wine you choose. Some wines naturally translate extremely well to kits and can taste very close to what you’d buy at the store, while others are more about easy drinking and simplicity.
Here are five wine styles that consistently produce results closest to store-bought wine, along with how to choose the right kit for each.
1. Cabernet Sauvignon (Full-Bodied & Structured)
If your goal is to make wine that feels like a proper store-bought bottle, Cabernet Sauvignon is one of the best choices.
It’s naturally bold, structured, and tannic — which helps give homemade wine that “real wine” feel. Even small improvements in quality are noticeable with this style, especially when you give it enough time to develop.
From experience: fuller-bodied reds like Cab consistently turn out the most impressive. They have weight, depth, and that familiar finish people expect.
Best approach:
- Go for longer kits when possible
- Give the wine extra time to age after bottling
👉 Browse options here:
RJS 6 Week Wine Kits
RJS 8 Week Wine Kits
2. Shiraz / Amarone Styles (Bold, Rich & Premium Feel)
If you want something that really feels like a premium bottle, bold styles like Shiraz or Amarone-style wines are excellent choices.
These wines are naturally rich, fruit-forward, and full-bodied. That intensity helps them come across as more “complete” and polished, even as a homemade wine.
From experience: Amarone-style kits (especially higher-end ones like En Primeur) can turn out surprisingly close to what you’d expect from a good store-bought red.
Why they work so well:
- Strong flavour profile
- Full body and mouthfeel
- Less noticeable imperfections
Best approach:
- Stick with longer kits for maximum depth
- Let them age — they improve significantly over time
👉 Explore premium styles:
RJS 8 Week Wine Kits
3. Merlot (Smooth, Easy “Store-Like” Red)
Merlot is one of the most forgiving and reliable styles you can make at home.
It’s softer than Cabernet, with less aggressive tannins, which makes it easier to get a clean, balanced result. That’s exactly why it often tastes very familiar — similar to many everyday wines you’d pick up at the store.
Why Merlot works well:
- Smooth and approachable
- Less sensitive to small mistakes
- Widely recognizable flavour profile
Best approach:
- Works great in both 5 and 6 week kits
- Ideal for beginners looking for consistent results
👉 Shop Merlot-friendly kits:
RJS 5 Week Wine Kits
RJS 6 Week Wine Kits
4. Pinot Grigio & Sauvignon Blanc (Crisp, Clean Whites)
White wines are interesting — they don’t need as much depth to feel “right.”
In fact, a lot of store-bought white wine is designed to be fresh, crisp, and easy to drink. That’s exactly where wine kits perform very well.
From experience: for whites, you don’t always need the most premium kit. Lower or mid-tier kits often produce very enjoyable results because the goal is simplicity and refreshment, not heavy structure.
Why they translate well:
- Clean fermentation profile
- Less reliance on aging
- Closer to everyday store-bought white styles
Best approach:
- 5 or 6 week kits are usually more than enough
- Great for casual drinking and entertaining
👉 Browse white wine kits:
RJS 5 Week Wine Kits
RJS 6 Week Wine Kits
5. Orchard Breezin’ (Easy-Drinking, Crowd-Pleasing Wines)
These are a different category — but still very relevant.
Orchard Breezin’ wine kits are designed to be light, fruit-forward, and refreshing. They don’t try to replicate a traditional premium wine — instead, they match the kind of easy-drinking wines and coolers many people already enjoy.
Why people love them:
- Very approachable
- Slightly sweet and refreshing
- Great for casual settings or warm weather
If you enjoy lighter wines or fruit-forward drinks from the store, these can feel very familiar and enjoyable.
So What Actually Makes a Wine Kit Taste Like Store-Bought Wine?
It’s not just the kit — it’s the combination of style + time + expectations.
- Full-bodied reds (Cab, Shiraz, Amarone-style) → closest to premium bottles
- Smooth reds (Merlot) → closest to everyday store wine
- Crisp whites → easy to replicate, even with simpler kits
- Fruit wines → similar to casual, easy-drinking options
Longer kits do help, especially for reds — but choosing the right style matters just as much.
Final Thoughts
Yes — homemade wine can absolutely taste like store-bought wine.
If you want the most impressive results, go for bold reds and give them time. If you want something easy and enjoyable, whites and shorter kits can deliver surprisingly good results with less effort.
Ultimately, the best wine kit is the one that matches how you actually like to drink wine.
Ready to get started? Explore all available options here:
